---
In a genre absolutely flooded with harem rom-coms where the bland male lead somehow attracts every beautiful girl in school, Makeine: Too Many Losing Heroines! flips the script in the most refreshing way possible – and does it with style, heart, and hilarious self-awareness.
The biggest strength, and what makes this show feel so unique, is its perspective: we follow Kazuhiko Nukumizu, a self-proclaimed "background character" (mob/mook/figurante) who actively tries to stay out of the spotlight. He's the kind of guy who eats lunch alone reading light novels, observes drama from afar, and has zero interest in becoming the center of attention. This is incredibly rare in romance anime – usually the protagonist is either the dense harem magnet or the cool transfer student. Here, the story is told from the viewpoint of the quiet observer, the extra in everyone else's love story, and that alone makes every interaction feel fresh and grounded.
Nukumizu keeps stumbling across popular, charismatic girls right after they've been rejected by their crushes – the classic "losing heroines" who, in any other rom-com, would be side characters designed to make the main girl look better by comparison. But Makeine says: wait, these girls have their own stories, pain, growth, and charm. Why do they always have to lose?
img (https://media1.tenor.com/m/D4ULdcSKI1EAAAAd/too-many-losing-heroines-makeine.gif)
What follows is a delightful mix of sharp comedy, genuine emotional moments, and surprisingly mature handling of heartbreak and moving on. The "losing heroines" – each with distinct personalities (the bubbly food-loving one, the energetic track star, the shy literature club member, and more) – drag the reluctant Nukumizu into their orbit, forming an unlikely support group built on shared meals, brutal honesty, and zero romantic pressure.
A-1 Pictures delivers gorgeous animation: fluid expressions, vibrant colors, creative direction that turns simple conversations into visual treats, and some of the best comedic timing I've seen all year. The voice acting is perfect – every line delivery feels natural, the banter crackles, and the quiet vulnerable moments hit hard.
But what elevates Makeine beyond just "good rom-com" is how it treats rejection and relationships with respect. No one is villainized for choosing someone else. Crushes aren't treated as eternal destiny. Healing comes from friendship, self-reflection, and finding joy outside of romance – all while poking fun at every trope in the book.
If you're tired of the same old harem formulas but still love witty dialogue, lovable characters, and feel-good vibes with real emotional depth, this is the show you've been waiting for. It's funny without being mean, heartfelt without being sappy, and subversive without feeling forced.
Score: 8/10 – Easily one of the best and most original rom-coms in years.
Season 2 can't come soon enough.
