SAO Review ___ Sword Art Online is one of those anime where I honestly think the internet went way too hard on it, especially when it comes to Season 1. It’s not perfect at all, but it’s also not anywhere near as bad as people make it out to be. What makes it frustrating is that it constantly shows flashes of something genuinely great, then pulls away before fully reaching that level. At the same time though, it’s fun, easy to watch, and has moments that stick with you, which is probably why it’s still talked about so much.

A big reason it sticks with me personally is because it was one of my first anime. I still remember watching it on YouTube back in 2016, not really knowing much about anime at the time. Everything about it felt new, the concept of being trapped in a game, the way the story mixed real stakes with a virtual world, and even just the structure of the episodes. That first experience definitely plays into how I see it now. There’s a strong nostalgic vibe attached to it that makes even its weaker parts more enjoyable, because it reminds me of that period where everything about anime felt fresh and interesting.

The Aincrad arc is easily the highlight of Season 1, and a lot of that comes down to its worldbuilding. The idea of a floating castle with 100 floors, each acting almost like its own mini world, is such a strong concept. Even though the show doesn’t fully explore every floor, the bits we do see are enough to give a sense of scale and possibility. Towns feel lived in, guilds form naturally, and there’s a clear sense of how players adapt to being stuck in this world long term. You see how some people try to live normal lives, while others focus entirely on clearing the game, and that contrast adds depth to the setting. It really feels like a society forming inside the game, which is one of the most interesting aspects of the arc.

At the same time, that’s also where one of its biggest flaws comes in. The pacing moves way too fast for a concept this big. Instead of gradually climbing through floors and building deeper connections with characters, the story often jumps ahead, skipping what could have been some of the most interesting parts. You get glimpses of something great, different environments, side characters, emotional stakes, but not enough time to fully explore them. It makes the world feel both expansive and underdeveloped at the same time, which is frustrating because you can clearly see the potential.

Kirito’s role in all of this works better than people give it credit for. His decision to isolate himself, the pressure of being a beta tester, and the weight of losing people all add layers to his character, especially early on. He’s not just overpowered for no reason, there’s context behind why he acts the way he does. That said, the show doesn’t always take the time to fully dive into those struggles, which again comes back to pacing.

Asuna is probably the standout character of the entire arc. She isn’t just there to support Kirito, she has her own presence, her own growth, and her own role within the world. Seeing her go from someone who’s initially overwhelmed by the situation to one of the strongest and most respected players in Aincrad is genuinely satisfying. She feels capable, independent, and emotionally grounded, which makes her relationship with Kirito feel more balanced than a lot of anime couples. Their dynamic is one of the strongest parts of the season, especially during the middle portion where they actually slow down and show them just living in the world together. Those quieter moments add a lot of charm and make the relationship feel real rather than rushed.

In terms of overall quality, Season 1 is a bit inconsistent but still strong where it matters. The animation, especially for its time, holds up well, and the fight scenes are memorable without feeling overly repetitive. The soundtrack also plays a huge role in setting the tone, making emotional scenes hit harder and giving the world a more immersive feel. Combined with the core concept, it creates an experience that’s easy to get invested in, even when the story stumbles.

Looking back on it now, Aincrad feels like a mix of missed potential and genuine quality. It’s the kind of arc that could have been amazing if it had more time to breathe, but even in its current form, it still delivers something memorable. And for me, a lot of that comes down to when and how I watched it. Being one of my first anime and experiencing it back in 2016 on YouTube gives it a nostalgic weight that’s hard to separate from the actual content. Even now, it still captures that feeling of discovering something new, which is probably why I still rate it highly despite its flaws.

Overall, Season 1, especially Aincrad, has its issues with pacing, some unnecessary elements, and missed opportunities, but it’s still a really enjoyable experience. It has strong ideas, memorable characters, and moments that genuinely hit. It doesn’t deserve the level of hate it gets, especially considering how much it influenced anime and how enjoyable it still is to watch. It’s not perfect but nothing is.

---

This review is purely based on my personal enjoyment