“I’m a Noble on the Brink of Ruin, So I Might as Well Try Mastering Magic” is (can you believe it?) an isekai based on a light novel; it follows our main character, Liam, as he’s reborn as the youngest son of a noble in a fantasy world. This could describe any number of isekai, but this is one of only 2 isekai from the winter 2025 season where the gimmick is that the MC is obsessed with magic. He goes from an unassuming spare son to an overpowered master of magic with a harem and his own nation over the course of this season and with a show this unoriginal, you could likely change a few words of this review and have it apply to a dozen other shows from recent years.
Story: 9/20
There’s not all that much to say about the story of this show; forgettable MC gets reincarnated, has an obsession with magic, gets Overpowered and proceeds to live out every shut-in’s wet dream. Harem? Check. Overwhelming power? Check. Founding a nation? Check. The score is the best description for this: 9/20. 45% just below average. There is a single word that people attribute to this show: forgettable. The story is just a step by step “he does this and then this and also then he does this” with no actual driving force behind it, no greater narrative purpose than to get Liam from the start of the story to the harem, power, the money, the self-insert goal.
PV: 10/20
I wouldn’t even go so far as to say the production value of this show was anything other than average, it wasn’t bad, it wasn’t good, it was just bland. The music was so forgettable that I already can’t remember the opening song and I listened to it 12 times these past 3 months. The character designs themselves were slightly better than average, but the animation did the art style no favours, dragging it right back down to the level of every other low-effort isekai we see season after season.
Characters: 10/20
Liam himself is just mass-produced self-insert #12554 with no personality beyond liking magic and being a vaguely decent person; this unfortunately drags down the rest of the cast. Scarlett, Chris, Flora, Radon, Asuna and any other character connected to Liam have no chance to actually be characters because the story demands that they revolve their interests, personalities and overall reason for being around Liam; with him being so boring, that unfortunately puts all other characters in the show in a position where they can’t actually be characters in their own right.
Enjoyment: 5/10
As I’m sure you can guess from everything above here, I’m not the biggest fan of this show; that said, I wouldn’t go so far as to call it “bad” - it’s not special, it’s not unique and it’s not interesting; what it is however, is a generic isekai, it’s noise; something I’d happily have on in the background while looking through my phone.
Success: 13/30
This is a show that goes for the low-effort, passionless route to making money. In a sense, you could say it’s deserving of a 30/30 here, as it certainly nailed the “passionless” part. With that said, it’s so low down because even an isekai that most people would dismiss at first glance can be good, even the bad ones tend to have some stand-out feature, but this show is so unremarkable that I’m actually sitting here, struggling to remember parts of it, mere hours after completing episode 12. I can’t imagine calling a show that forgettable a success.
Overall: 47/100
An inoffensive, bland power fantasy show - the review could honestly be boiled down to that and that alone. I find myself slightly disappointed in this one though, it kept seeming like something would happen to shake up the formula, but it never did. Something that honestly confused me was Radon, the dragon god. How did she come to be trapped by a minor noble house? Why didn’t she care that Liam murdered her children when they first met? And finally, why did she have to transform into a Loli? If another season ever comes, I’ll probably watch it, but those who don’t bother with this show or wouldn’t bother with a hypothetical season 2 aren’t missing out on much.
25.5 out of 29 users liked this review
