SapphicNohrian

10- Makes a profound thematic statement and has no significant flaws.
9- Makes a profound thematic statement but has one major flaw.
8- Fun, not deep, has no significant flaws./Has a profound theme but several major flaws.
7- Fun, not deep, has one or more significant flaws.
6- Unremarkable aside from one or two significant virtues.
5- Unremarkable.
4- Virtues are outnumbered and outweighed by a multitude of flaws.
3- Thematically empty and largely flawed works with several redeeming virtues.
2- Ethically repugnant works (i,e., works that do not merely fail to make a thematic statement but actively make statements that are harmful, disgusting and false) that still have several notable virtues./Thematically empty works with one redeeming virtue.
1- Ethically repugnant works with one small redeeming factor./Thematically empty works with no redeeming virtue.
0- Ethically repugnant and without any kind of redeeming virtue.