I'm using the more advanced scores for all of the anime and manga.
The grades are finalized based on my score for these categories:
- Story: How well is the plot structured? How do we gain information and resolve conflicts in the story? How well does the theme interact with the events of the story?
- Characters: How well does the character serve their purpose in the story? Do their decisions and motivations enhance the story? Do character interactions enhance the story?
- Visuals: Are the visuals (action) clear and understandable? Does the art enhance the reading experience? Is the character design done well?
- The World: Does the story explore the scope of its world? If there is a fighting/magic system, is it creative or well structured? Are the places or creatures in the world interesting/unique?
- Enjoyment: Do I have fun reading/watching this? Do I care about any of the world, the characters, or the story? Were there any (or many) dull moments? Would I recommend this to anyone?